Monday, October 02, 2006

Ray copies Ray index

This index lists game notes by Ray Keene that have been found to be reproduced in different places, substantially or entirely, without acknowledgement.

As with the Ray Keene Plagiarism Index it lists only those examples which have been documented online, which is only a very small proportion of those uncovered*.

UPDATE: I largely suspended work on this index after discovering more than eighty examples in The Times Little Book Of Chess Secrets (Harper Collins, 2013) alone, on the grounds that the work of documentation was too extensive to be a practical proposition. More than four hundred examples of recycling have so far been detected.


Adams-Carlsen, Olympiad 2010. Times 29 September 2010, 12 April 2011, 30 July 2011, 2 December 2011 and 13 March 2012. Spectator 9 October 2010.
Alekhine-Bogolyubow,  match, 1929 (5). Times 5 June 2013 and The Times Little Book Of Chess Secrets (Harper Collins, 2013). (The notes were plagiarised in both cases.)
Anand-Kasparov, New York 1995 (13). Spectator 22 September 2001, 13 December 1997, and 7 October 1995. World Chess Champonship: Kasparov v Anand (Batsford 1995).
Benko-Petrosian, Los Angeles 1963. Times 28 August 2013. Petrosian vs the Elite (Batsford 2006).
Botvinnik-Petrosian, match, Moscow 1963 (14). Times 20 August 2011 and 6 June 2013. Times Little Book Of Chess Secrets (Harper Collins 2013). (The notes were plagiarised in all cases.)
Carlsen-Nakamura, Medias 2011. Spectator 25 June 2011. Times January 11 2012. Sunday Times 17 March 2013.
Corden-Williams, Varsity Match 1970. Spectator 8 May 2004. Times 5 March 2011 and 4 March 2000.
Gelfand-Beliavsky, Linares 1990. Spectator 10 March 1990 and 22 December 1990.
Hartston-Bellon. Spectator 31 October 1988. Times 23 July 2013.
Hartston-Westerinen, Alicante 1973. Spectator 11 December 2004 and 14 April 2012. (The column was repeated: the notes were plagiarised in both cases.)
Howell-Gordon, Torquay 2009. Times 1 August 2013 and 29 September 2011. Spectator 15 August 2009 and 22 August 2009.
Howell-Pert, Sheffield 2011. Times 2 August 2013 and 5 August 2011.
Ivanchuk-Kramnik, Las Palmas 1996. Spectator 4 January 1997 and 20 July 2013.
Ivanchuk-Shirov, Wijk aan Zee 1996. Spectator 20 March 1996 and 29 September 2000. Times 18 December 1999, 27 January 2012 and 20 July 2013.
Jones-Rendle, Sheffield 2011. Times 31 July 2013 and 4 August 2011.
Jones-Short, Bunratty 2011. Times 18 April 2011, 5 July 2012 and 30 July 2013.
Jones-Turner, North Shields 2012. Times 29 July 2013 and 15 August 2012.
Karpov-Miles, Bath 1983. Spectator, 21 June 2003 and 10 August 2013. Times 15 November 2011. Spectator Book Of Chess (Hardinge Simpole 2004). Tony Miles: England's Chess Gladiator (Hardinge Simpole 2006).
Kasparov-Ivanchuk, Horgen 1995. Spectator 11 November 1995. Sunday Times 21 July 2013.
Kasparov-Karpov, match, Moscow 1984/5, games 9, 13, 16 and 32. Spectator, 13 October 1984, 27 October 1984, 3 November 1984, 22 December 1984. The Moscow Challenge (Batsford, 1985).
Keres-Petrosian, Candidates 1959. Sunday Times 25 August 2013. Petrosian vs the Elite (Batsford 2006). Learn from the Grandmasters (Batsford 1975).
Kramnik-Leko, match, Dortmund 2004 (8). Spectator 16 October 2004. Times 2 December 2010, 24 August 2012 and 23 April 2013.
Kramnik-Leko, match, Dortmund 2004 (14). Spectator 23 October 2004. Times 20 August 2010.
Kramnik-Leko, Mexico 2007. Times 22 October 2010 and 21 September 2011. Spectator 13 October 2007.
Lasker-Chigorin, Hastings 1895. Times 3 January 2012 and 24 December 2012. (The notes were plagiarised in both cases.)
Nakamura-Adams, London 2011. 21 December 2011 and 11 December 2014. Sunday Times 25 November 2012.
Nakamura-Gelfand, London 2013. Times 23 December 2013 and 9 December 2014.
Olafsson-Wade, Reykjavik 1964. Spectator 6 December 2008 and 10 May 2003. Times 22 July 2013.
Panno-Petrosian, Candidates 1956 (fragment). Spectator 8 June 2002. Petrosian vs the Elite (Batsford 2006).
Parker-Rowson, Swansea 2006. Times 20 July 2012 and 26 July 2010.
Penrose-Goldenberg, world correspondence championship 1989-91. Times 24 July 2013 and 19 October 1996.
Penrose-Keene, Blackpool 1971. Times 26 July 2013, 23 July 2011, 17 April 2012 and 24 July 2012. Becoming A Grandmaster (Batsford 1977). British Chess Magazine October 1971.
Petrosian-Benko, Los Angeles 1963. Times 29 August 2013. Petrosian vs the Elite (Batsford 2006).
Petrosian-Bronstein, Candidates 1956 (fragment). Spectator 8 June 2002. Petrosian vs the Elite (Batsford 2006).
Petrosian-Botvinnik, Moscow 1963. Times 24 August 2013. Petrosian vs the Elite (Batsford 2006).
Petrosian-Gligoric, Los Angeles, 1963. Times 27 August 2013. Petrosian vs the Elite (Batsford 2006).
Petrosian-Keres, Candidates 1956 (fragment). Spectator 8 June 2002. Petrosian vs the Elite (Batsford 2006).
Petrosian-Psakhis, Las Palmas 1982. Times 30 August 2013. Petrosian vs the Elite (Batsford 2006).
Petrosian-Spassky, Candidates 1956 (fragment). Spectator 8 June 2002. Petrosian vs the Elite (Batsford 2006).
Petrosian-Tal, Moscow 1963. Times 29 August 2013. Petrosian vs the Elite (Batsford 2006).
Short-Kramnik, London 2010. Times 15 December 2010, 29 November 2011, 16 March 2013 and 12 December 2014.
Smyslov-Petrosian, Candidates 1956 (fragment). Spectator 8 June 2002. Petrosian vs the Elite (Batsford 2006).
Topalov-Kramnik, match, Elista 2006 (2). Times 6 December 2010 and 13 June 2013.


Also see:

Ivanchuk v Anand, Linares 1998. Spectator 21 March 1998, 5 May 2012, 22 June 2013. (Scroll to Chess Note 8100.)




[* Let alone the likely total. Note: the original place of publication not known for sure unless stated. We would of course welcome more information of any relevant kind, including examples of copying, from readers.]

[Last updated 23 December 2014. This index created July 2013 - please ignore posting date!]
[Ray Keene index]

No comments: